Sometimes good witch Cassie Nightingale wishes she could look into the future like when stepson Brandon suddenly moves up his wedding date, leaving Cassie with only days to organize the event. Help is on its way, however, when a pleasant young woman named Audrey enters Cassie's shop looking for a job. The two women hit it off instantly, and Cassie feels she can trust her a hundred percent. With the shop humming along under Audrey's expert supervision, Cassie can turn her attention to Brandon, who's getting cold feet. After a heart-to-heart talk with him, Cassie knows that Brandon's I do will ring out loud and clear at the altar. Also making demands on her time and patience is the town's big charity auction. Curiously, Audrey seems fascinated by the auction; but when both she and the auction items including a precious family memento of Cassie's disappear, suspicion falls on Audrey, who is indeed hiding a dark secret. Now it's time to put her friendship with Cassie to the test...